Alex has never been professionally involved into the world of coffee, however he knows much more than any average barista. Being an avid coffee lover, Alex is constantly searching for new tips, tools, and techniques to make his morning cup of java even more perfect.
Dominic has been dealing with coffee almost all his life long: in his teenage years he worked as a barista in a number of well-known coffeehouses, later developing his knowledge and skills while studying at the university as well. Several years after the graduation, he managed to open his own small coffee bar, which turned into a chain spread all over the state.
The world of K-Cup coffee can appear a little scary if you aren’t sure of what you are looking for. Here is where we come in to help. Are you on a quest to find your new favorite K-Cup coffee blend? Or maybe you just got a K-Cup brewer and have no clue what the best K-Cup coffee blends are that you should try? Well, look no further. Here we have some of the most popular brands, flavors, and styles to read up on with comprehensive pros and cons and ratings.
You may not think so, but coffee is incredibly complex. It is full of tastes, types, origins, roasts, and pack sizes. It is by no means a piece of cake to dive into by yourself. But that is why we are here! To help walk you through all the varieties and blends to land you with the best K-Cup coffee, you could want.
The SF Bay Coffee Variety Pack offers customers a choice of four blends of delicious Arabica coffee from Central and South America, ranging from medium to dark roast. The robust and dark French Roast has beautiful notes of warm cinnamon, while the medium to dark roast Fog Chaser will please the palate with just a touch of toffee. The medium roasts Breakfast Blend and Organic Rainforest Blend have hints of chocolate and jasmine, respectively. This pack comes with 80 Keurig-compatible K-Cup pods that are Orthodox Union Kosher certified and ethically sourced. The coffee itself is grown using sustainable, innovative farming methods, and the family-owned company uses fair-trade employment. Additionally, the commercially compostable and BPI certified, plant-based packing will please even the greenest of green thumbs!
Flavorful and robust
Fairtrade and Orthodox Union Kosher certified
Variety of blends and roasts
Sustainable farming methods
Keurig Brewer compatible
Not suitable for backyard composting
Should be stored in an airtight container at risk of losing flavor
Dive into Keurig K-Cup Pod Variety Pack and enjoy a taste of each of the most popular Keurig brand K-Cup pods! This pack spans blends such as the nutty and bright Green Mountain Breakfast Blend Light Roast and the intense, full-bodied Tully’s Dark French Roast. The range of blends provides customers with the best variety of K-Cup flavors and roasts to find their favorite or branch out to new options! Sweet blends Original Donut Shop and Green Mountain Caramel Vanilla Cream satisfy the sweet tooth without overpowering the natural coffee flavors. The unique Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend incorporates both the rich, spiced notes of Indonesian beans with the energetic and fresh finish of a Central American bean. Fans of organic will be happy to know that Newman’s Own Organic Special Blend Fair-trade K-Cups come with this pack. The 72 plastic Keurig Cup pods will assure that you will have plenty of each blend, roast, and flavor!
Compatible with all Keurig brewers
Wide variety of roasts, blends, and flavors
Great for finding your new go-to Keurig K-Cup blend
If you love fair-trade and sustainably grown coffee and K-Cup products, you will really love Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Kenya Highlands. Grown in the hills of Kenya by dedicated farmers, the full-bodied medium roast incorporates fruity notes into each smooth cup, as well as a delicious blackberry finish that balances the heartiness and earthy tones of the Arabica beans. Kenya Highlands is a pleasant mix of rich and bright notes that make for a smooth and delightful cup. The pack comes with 72 Keurig K-Cup pods that are compatible with all Keurig Brewers, including the new Keurig 2.0. Additionally, they are certified Orthodox Union Kosher. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters is committed to reaching 100% responsibly sourced coffee beans by the end of 2020, so you know that your coffee is good for you and the planet!
Flavorful and unique medium roast
Committed to sustainability
Orthodox Union Kosher certified
Compatible with all Keurig Brewers
Some costumers have experienced issues with the condition of the products upon arrival
The Original Donut Shop Keurig K-Cups are a favorite of young and old alike. The bold medium roasts skip the bitterness usually found in some medium roasts and hits the taste buds with the nostalgia of the classic coffee shop taste. Made from Arabica beans and inspired by the old-school donut shop flavor profile, it is widely regarded as one of the best blends available to Keurig Brewers. The pack contains 72 K-Cup pods that are compatible with all Keurig Brewers, including the newer Keurig 2.0. Original Donut Shop Coffee is also available in Decaf and Extra Bold, making it some of the best decaf K-Cup coffee around. Extra Bold has more coffee in each K-Cup pod rather than changing the roast level, which preserves the flavor of the blend. The Original Donut Shop is also Orthodox Union Kosher certified!
Solimo Kona Blend is a medium roast that packs a sweet, smooth, and well-balanced flavor, and is regarded by many as the best Kona K-Cup coffee for its price point! The value of the Solimo Kona Blend is highly regarded as the best value K-Cup pod blend, coming in a pack of 100 K-Cup pods for $29.99. The 10% Kona coffee beans blended with Arabica give coffee drinkers a full-bodied yet silky flavor that has a delicious yet subtle aroma to match. The Kona beans are grown in the volcanic soil of Hawaii in special conditions, giving this Kona K-Cup coffee the quality and value that surpasses other Kona K-Cup options. These K-Cup pods are compatible with all Keurig Brewers! Included in your purchase of this pack comes to a satisfaction guarantee making it a great first Kona K-Cup to try!
If you enjoy Peet’s Coffee in the shop or are looking to transition from loose Peet’s Coffee grounds to K-Cups, Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s Blend is the perfect way to bring the Peet’s coffee shop flavor to your Keurig! This dark and bodied blend is chock-full of rich, complex, and smooth flavors that satisfy all lovers of Peet’s Coffee and a true, smooth, dark roast coffee! The unique blend of Arabica coffee beans from around the world makes it a trip around the globe with every sip. Every Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s Blend comes with 75 K-Cup pods that hold hand-roasted coffee in each pod. These dark roast pods are compatible with Keurig Brewers, (including the new model the Keurig 2.0) and have a pleasant aroma when brewed!
The classic flavor of Peet's Coffee, but in your kitchen
Complex, yet smooth dark roast
Compatible with Keurig Brewers
One of the best K-Cups for stronger coffee
No eco-friendly packing
Occasional issues reported involving the Keurig Brewer not recognizing the K-Cup pod
With unique flavors that blend together in harmony, Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend K-Cup pods are a warm sip of excitement every time! Sweetness and spice mixed with notes of ripe berries turn into touches of bittersweet cocoa and ends with a smoky, cedar finish. These Arabica coffee beans from Central and South America are not just good for your morning cup of Joe, but also for the planet, as this blend of K-Cup pods is Rainforest Alliance certified! Costumers love the smooth flavor that does not have an overpowering bitterness. Each pack comes with 72 individual K-Cup pods full of coffee that has been grown sustainably and responsibly. Caribou Coffee ensures that all of their farmers are fairly compensated, and was the first coffeehouse in the United States to exclusively serve Coffee certified by the Rainforest Alliance.
If you are a Krispy Kreme Doughnut lover and a coffee lover, then Krispy Kreme Classic K-Cup pods are a sweet way to start your day, any day! The legendary, classic, combination of coffee and doughnut is taken further in these classic K-Cups. You can bring the flavor of doughnut and coffee into your kitchen to enjoy every day! The medium roast starts with a smooth sip that gradually brightens up until it is full of fruity notes that mellow out into a clean, sweet, and satisfying finish, just like a Krispy Kreme Doughnut. This brew is perfect for satisfying the craving for a Krispy Kreme Doughnut, without leaving your house! This pack of 48 K-Cup pods is also kosher certified and compatible with all Keurig Brewers including the Keurig 2.0! Along with regular, there is a decaf option that has been praised by some costumers as the best decaf K-Cup coffee on the market!
If you like to enjoy a smooth, bold cup of coffee with a robust aroma, then the CozyUp Breakfast Blend is the K-Cup pod you should be putting into your single serve coffee brewer! This medium roast leans towards the darker, more intense side, but it is always a silky sip with lovely hints of cocoa that add to the enjoyment of every cup of coffee. The aroma of CozyUp Breakfast Blend K-Cup pods has been praised for its satisfying and mouth-watering scent that will waft around your kitchen. This CozyUp pack has 100 K-Cups manufactured in the United States with absolutely no artificial ingredients, so you know that your coffee is that much better! Additionally, CozyUp Breakfast Blend is labeled as compatible with all Keurig Brewers.
A strong and delicious aroma
Classic flavor with soft cocoa notes
Manufactured in the United States
No artificial ingredients
The roast level is more medium to dark than medium
A few customer reports of K-Cup pods not working in their Keurig Brewer 2.0
The Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend is a blend of medium to dark roast Arabica beans from Central America and Indonesia, give it a bold flavor that is both smooth and strong. The aroma is just like the taste; refined, hearty, and bodied. In addition to its robust flavor in your morning coffee, Newman’s Own gives all profits to charity, so you get a great cup of Joe while supporting a non-profit! This Keurig Brand K-Cup pack comes with 72 K-Cup pods that are full of fair-trade, as well as USDA certified! These K-Cup pods are also organic and Orthodox Union Kosher certified! The Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend has both regular (caffeinated) and water-processed decaffeinated K-Cup pod options. Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend is also often considered the best organic K-Cup coffee by many K-Cup users!
If you are a fan of a classic, smooth, medium roast cup of coffee in the morning or any time of day, then Eight O’Clock Coffee The Original is the K-Cup pack you have been looking for! Medium roasted Arabica coffee beans form a complex yet silky brew that will give you the cure to your coffee fix even after eight O’clock! Each Eight O’Clock Coffee The Original pack comes with 72 K-Cup pods full of 100% Arabica coffee packaged in six boxes with twelve K-Cup pods per box. Eight O’Clock Coffee The Original may seem simple, but the classic flavors never go out of style, and the delightful aroma that comes from each K-Cup brewed will do the trick every time! Eight O’Clock Coffee The Original is also Orthodox Union Kosher certified.
If you’ve got a sweet tooth and love coffee, you will love the way the sweetness of caramel and tasty tropical coconut mixes into a nutty delight in Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods! Hawaiian Arabica beans are brought to a medium roast and flavored with the warm tones of sweet caramel and the bright, fruity notes of fresh coconut. Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods are aromatically pleasing and enticing, bringing the classic coffee scent with touches of nutty caramel. For those who love the environment as much as a good cup of coffee, you can sip easy knowing that Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods use less plastic than traditional K-Cup pods! Kauai Coffee also practices sustainable farming, packaging, and roasting! Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods are also compatible with all Keurig Brewers including the Keurig 2.0. Each four-pack of Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods has 48 delicious cups inside, waiting to be brewed!
The sweet, nutty, unique flavor profile
Designed to use less plastic per K-Cup
Strong aromatic presence
Well blended flavors
More of a medium to dark roast than a medium
Things like taste, roast, pack size, and compatibility might not be what you think of when you go to purchase your K-Cups, but they are hugely important to how you will enjoy your coffee. Different flavors come from different countries and growing solid, while some are artificial. Becoming knowledgeable about your coffee and its components is very important when starting (or furthering) your search for the perfect K-Cup.
Love for K-Cup coffee
It is so easy to fall in love with K-Cup pods and single cup coffee brewers— they are easy, low maintenance, and brew much faster than traditional coffee pots. As more flavors and blends come to your attention, and you will simply fall more in love with the convenience and satisfaction of K-Cup coffee! What’s not to love? There is no mess, no wait time, just delicious coffee in minutes! If you an avid coffee drinker, you will truly enjoy the ease in which you can make a fresh cup of Joe. Or if you are constantly running late in the morning, K-Cups will be there to quickly give you the wake-up boost you need to rush off into the day.
Features to consider when you choose K-Cup coffee
When purchasing K-Cup coffee pods or any type of coffee, it is important to know what makes up the coffee that you love and why. As crazy as it may seem, there is a difference between taste and flavoring, and origin and type. It can feel daunting when you look at a box, and there are so many different words telling you what the coffee is like, but none of them make any sense. So, here are some components that will help you figure out what features make up the coffee that you like the most!
The type indicates what kind of coffee beans are being used. Arabica, Colombian and Kona are all variations of types of coffee beans. The Solimo Kona Blend is a blend of both Kona and Arabica coffee beans. Arabica is the most common type of bean to be used, since it is not as intense, but can be roasted more to bring out lots of flavors or lightly roasted to keep it light.
Different types have different qualities that they are known for, for example, Arabica is the most versatile, so it is used in lots of blends and mixes.
Origin is the place where the beans themselves were grown. Several of the most popular origins for coffee beans are Central and South America, Indonesia, Africa, and Hawaii. Different environments create different flavors in the beans. For example, beans grown in Indonesia, like for Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend, have a hazy, spiced flavor and aroma while beans from Central America have a fruitier disposition. The origin location often will tell you a bit about the taste you can expect from a coffee blend.
The roast level indicates how long the coffee beans were roasted. The longer the beans are roasted, the darker and stronger the coffee will be after it is brewed. Lighter roasts have a soft flavor, while dark roasts have a strong, more bitter flavor. Green Mountain Breakfast Blend Light Roast and Tully’s Dark French Roast are two prime examples of each roast. There is also medium roast which, you guessed it, is in the middle of light and dark roasts.
Most people find a medium roast enjoyable since they are flavorful, but not too intense or overpowering.
The taste is very important when it comes to coffee. If bitter tastes bother you, then a blend that has notes of lighter and fruity flavors like Green Mountain Kenyan Highlands can help balance the taste. The taste is primarily the undertones of the coffee and can be smoky, bright, sweet, and many more. Taste can often be confused with added flavoring, but the taste comes directly from the coffee beans themselves and is why beans from certain locations produce similar tastes. The taste of beans from Indonesia is heavier and spiced, while Central America produces brighter tones and fruity aspects.
The sizes of K-Cup packs vary, some have 100 while others have 48. The pack size you purchase depends on the amount of coffee you consume daily. If you tend to drink coffee like you breathe air, a larger pack size like CozyUp Breakfast Blend has 100 per box will last longer than Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods, which come in packs of 48. Pack size should also be compared to the price to see if the cost for the number of pods in one bigger pack is more or less than buying two boxes of a smaller pack.
Compatibility with Keurig machines
Depending on the K-Cup machine you own, some K-Cup pods may work, while others will not. It depends on the model of the brewer as well as the K-Cups. Some K-Cups will work in every single pod coffee brewer like the Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods, while others say they will work, but when they are placed in the spot, the machine does not recognize the K-Cup and will not brew the pod. The new Keurig 2.0 works with all Keurig K-Cup products but can be finicky with others, so if you own this brewer make sure to check the K-Cup pods to see if they will work with your machine.
Most people enjoy the energy that caffeinated coffee brings, but it is not for everyone. Decaf coffee usually has a similar taste as regular coffee, but with no caffeine. The best decaf K-Cup coffee is varying wildly, however many people enjoy The Original Donut Shop and Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend in their decaf forms since they tend to preserve the flavor of the original the best.
Some coffees are decaffeinated through a chemical process while others go through a water process.
Depending on how you feel about each process (and about decaf coffee in general,) you can make your choice. When you go to purchase decaf, you should be able to check the packing to see what process was used to decaffeinate your coffee.
Added flavorings can overpower some people, but other people love them! Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods have added flavorings of caramel and coconut, and it is their most popular blend! The flavorings can vary from brand to brand, and some you may enjoy more than others. Added flavorings can often imply artificial tastes, but that is not always the case. The Kauai Coffee Single Serve Pods have both natural and artificial flavorings. The flavorings themselves will vary with each brand, as some may use exclusively natural flavorings while others will rely on artificial flavoring.
Yes, it is healthy to drink K-Cup coffee because K-Cup coffee is no different from any other coffee. No research shows K-Cup and single-serve pods being harmful to the body in any way. K-Cup pods are just single serving sizes for more convenience in our busy world. Why would you wait 20 minutes for one cup of coffee from a coffee pot when you can have the exact same cup of coffee in 5 minutes with no mess? K-Cups are quick and progressive alternatives to the slow-paced coffee pots of the past. It is the same coffee going into each brewer, so the health effects remain the same.
K-Cup pods are not recyclable as a whole, but with a little effort, they can be! Since K-Cup typically are made out of aluminum and plastic, they must be separated. If the K-Cup has an aluminum lid, it must be removed and recycled with metal and glass materials like cans and bottles. The coffee grounds must be removed from the plastic cup (the coffee grounds can be used in backyard compost and are great for gardens,) and the cup then rinsed before it is put into plastic recycling. In some towns, plastic and metal recycling are picked up together. In that case, the lid needs to be removed to clean out the coffee grounds before putting the pod into the recycling.
Coffee is a very personal preference, however, our Editor’s Choice, Best Value, and Premium Pick are definitely ones to consider when purchasing your K-Cups as they can, help save your planet, help save you money and, of course, give you a wide variety of delicious coffees to explore. In addition to those three options, the two blends that are tied for the title of best K-Cup coffees are SF Bay Coffee Variety Pack and The Original Donut Shop due to their overall ratings. However, the SF Bay Coffee Variety Pack will take home the title as best K-Cup coffee since it is both Editors’ Choice and top-rated overall. The best K-Cup for you may be one of our favorites, but it could also be any number of K-Cup coffees! The best K-Cup coffee is out there for you, all that left to do is start brewing!