Alex has never been professionally involved into the world of coffee, however he knows much more than any average barista. Being an avid coffee lover, Alex is constantly searching for new tips, tools, and techniques to make his morning cup of java even more perfect.
Mary has been dealing with coffee almost all her life long: in her teenage years, she worked as a barista in a number of well-known coffeehouses, later developing her knowledge and skills while studying at the university as well. Several years after graduation, she managed to open her own small coffee bar.
Last updated: March 29, 2021
Coffee Statistics is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Coffee Statistics is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
If you are a coffee connoisseur who is seeking the ideal type of coffee makers to keep your drink hot for many hours without it getting burnt, then you should invest in the best thermal coffee maker. It keeps your coffee hot without compromising its taste so you can enjoy a steady supply of your favorite caffeinated beverage.
When shopping for these appliances, consider key features such as the capacity, if the model is programmable, its dimensions, filters, warranty and brewing options, among others. Assessing the dimensions and capacity of your prospective unit will identify the right model that will fit in the space available and dispense enough cups of coffee to meet your demands while programmable functionality allows you to schedule brewing to a specified time so you can instantly access coffee at your convenience. Multiple brewing options provide versatile settings which enable you to customize the strength, flavor and the type of coffee blend to your preference. A warranty insures you against future defects. Lastly, a filter is essential because it optimizes extraction to avoid a drink with sediments and bitter taste. It also removes chlorine and other impurities from water which may alter the flavor of your coffee.
To determine the best thermal coffee maker on the market, we researched several models and feedback by customers and expert reviewers. In this review, you will find a list of the top-rated products, a comparison table, detailed reviews of each model we have recommended, and a comprehensive buying guide which expounds more on the most important features to consider before buying a thermal coffee maker.
This is the best 12 cup coffee maker with thermal carafe for coffee aficionados who enjoy making a variety of coffee blends because it comes with a number of strength settings and a 24-hour programmable timer that allows you to set the unit to automatically start brewing at a specified time so you can readily access your coffee whenever you wish.
Other convenient features that you will like in Cuisinart DCC-3400 are its ability to self-clean and restore your previous settings within 60 seconds once power resumes after an outage so you won’t have to reset the unit. There’s also an automatic shut-off function after brewing is completed.
The coffee appliance also lets you select regular or bold strength option, brew 1 to 4 cups, pause brewing mid-cycle to pour out a cup of coffee from the stainless steel thermal carafe, and turn off the ready alert tone to minimize disruptions.
Water is filtered with a GoldTone coffee filter and charcoal filter to eliminate impurities and the clear window makes it easy to keep tabs on the water level. Other settings are displayed on the backlit LCD screen while an indicator light notifies you when you should decalcify.
The large number of verified buyers and the high ratings they have awarded this Cuisinart coffee maker is a proof of its popularity and performance. The main issue seems to be the design of the carafe which requires you to remove the lid and turn the carafe upside down to pour the last cups of coffee.
Breville is known for making high-quality appliances used to prepare food and drinks. Breville BDC450 Precision Brewer Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe has been certified by Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) for adhering to the strict parameters related to brewing time and water temperature and for making one for best 12 cup coffee maker with thermal carafe. Instead of aluminum, it utilizes Thermocoil Heating System to enhance the water’s purity and features PID Control which allows you to adjust temperature to the precise one required for your coffee blend. You can also adjust the bloom time, flow rate and the brewing time in My Brew mode to customize your coffee to a floral, earthy or fruity flavor.
The appliance comes with a pump which provides three flow rates, a dual filter basket consisting of flat bottom and cone filter baskets for brewing varied volumes of coffee and auto ‘Steep and Release’ valve which saturates and extracts the full flavor of coffee in the absence of the carafe. When you activate preset mode, the unit automatically selects the best temperature and brewing time among six different brewing settings for optimal output. These preset settings are Gold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew, and My Brew. Alternatively, you can opt for an adapter to make pour-over drinks, which eliminates the need for a kettle to heat water separately or an extra appliance to make cold brews. The adapter is available for purchase separately. Some customers also noted that the unit is louder than similar coffee machines.
BUNN BT Velocity Brew 10-Cup Coffee Brewer is a basic no-frills unit designed for home use. However, it brews coffee fast and maintains optimal temperature while keeping coffee hot in a double-wall, vacuum-insulated carafe for up to two hours.
The 800-watt heater, integrated thermostat and the internal water tank made of stainless steel work together to keep water heated to optimal brewing temperature of 200° F while the showerhead sprays water to wet the ground coffee evenly for maximum extraction of aroma and flavor to brew up to ten cups of coffee in approximately three minutes.
Although this model makes one of the best yet affordable automatic drip coffee makers with thermal carafe which work well with coarse ground coffee, a finer grind may yield less than desirable results because the high flow rate of water causes the filter basket to overflow with ground coffee which may seep into your cup. To avoid this, customers order a restricted flow showerhead from BUNN at no additional cost. You will also have to contend with making your coffee on demand because there are no programmable settings to schedule or customize brewing. This may actually be advantageous to baristas who prefer manual operation which grants greater control over all stages of the brewing process as opposed to the convenience of automated preset settings. You will also benefit from the small footprint which will easily fit in with your other appliances.
Motif Elements Pour-Over Style Coffee Brewer with Thermal Carafe features elbow-shaped corners which facilitate easy removal of the filter basket and the water reservoir and a showerhead which sprays water all over on coffee grounds for even saturation.
A superior water heater quickly achieves the ideal brewing temperature within 60 seconds to ready the unit for pre-infusion mode which simulates manual pour-over method. This process involves dampening coffee grounds for 20 seconds, followed by release of gas and pause in flow rate for 30 seconds during blooming to promote maximum water absorption. Once the water resumes flowing, a temperature of 198º F to 205º F is maintained in the course of the brewing cycle to extract full-bodied flavor.
The manufacturer recommends using 65 grams of ground coffee for an 8-cup pot and sustaining steeping for 4 to 8 minutes to optimize flavor extraction.
This thermal coffee maker is equipped with two separate heaters for warming and brewing, a handy addition which ensures your drink remains hot for as long as you wish without overheating it to prevent a bitter taste.
Other notable features that contribute to making this model the best thermal carafe coffee maker include an advanced decalcification sensor which notifies you when the appliance is due for cleaning and audible notifications that indicate the start and completion of a brew cycle. The sensor compares your usage rate and the power consumption and monitors accumulation of calcium to avoid limiting the overall performance of your thermal coffee maker.
Owners like the convenient filling of the removable water dispenser, quick brewing, double-walled stainless steel thermal carafe, and the timer. A minor annoyance is the bit of water that always remains in the filter basket.
This model is part of Zojirushi products which manufactures a broad variety of stainless-steel vacuum bottles, rice cookers, breadmakers, Air Pot beverage dispensers, thermal serving carafes and specialty cookware. Zojirushi Corporation celebrated its centenary anniversary in 2018.
The Zojirushi EC-YTC100XB Coffee Maker comes with a removable water tank with clear markings, a reusable and washable permanent stainless mesh coffee filter, a Swing Basket and Filter Basket which are easily lifted out for cleaning, and a measuring spoon.
In the Pre-Infusion Cycle, water wets the ground coffee to allow blooming before brewing to yield optimal flavor and aroma for 10 cups of hot coffee or up to 5 cups of concentrated iced coffee which is made by adjusting the ratio of water to coffee to avoid a diluted, bland beverage. As one of the best drip coffee makers with thermal carafe, this unit has mechanism in place to prevent coffee from dripping when the carafe is removed and a 24-hour programmable timer which delays the brewing process to your preferred time so you can wake up to fresh coffee in the morning and still enjoy more of it later because the stainless steel carafe is vacuum insulated to keep it hot for hours without the burnt taste.
Customers appreciate the cleaning alerts, the optional time saver mode which speeds up brewing time and the mutable sound signal which makes this model ideal for offices or late-night brewing. The timer and clock also have memory so you won’t need to reset the unit if you unplug it.
Some buyers find the size of this coffee maker, particularly the height, quite large, especially regarding not the most capacious carafe.
If you are looking for the best pocket-friendly automatic drip coffee maker with thermal carafe which brews ten cups in less than seven minutes and is friendly to your pockets, then Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX95 Thermal Coffee Maker would be the most valuable option for you. It meets the approved industry standard which requires coffee makers to maintain temperatures of 195° to 205° F for five or six minutes for optimal extraction and brewing of coffee.
Both the filter basket and water reservoir can be removed for cleaning and filling and the built-in water filter removes chlorine and other impurities from water to avoid altering the taste of coffee. It also has a special cleaning cycle to reduce accumulation of calcium.
A high temperature of up to 205 degrees Celsius shortens the overall brewing time by up to 20% while the Delay Brew setting lets you schedule the brewing process to any time you wish to have a ready drink.
The bestselling model features an auto-pause function to pour out a cup of coffee and replenish during the brewing cycle, double-walled, stainless steel thermal carafe to keep the coffee hot for 2 to 4 hours without risking over-extraction, and a 2-hour safety auto shut-off feature that automatically shuts off the unit to save energy.
Unfortunately, you cannot adjust the strength of your brew and a few buyers have reported leakage.
Our Budget pick is the BLACK+DECKER Thermal Coffee Maker which comes with a double-walled and vacuum-sealed dishwasher safe carafe that holds 12 cups of coffee and varied settings which you can tweak to customize the brew strength and the volume of your specialty blend. This allows you to make smaller batches of 1 to 4 cups of coffee of regular, strong, and bold strength and a full-bodied flavor produced by the Evenstream Showerhead which distributes water evenly over ground coffee.
The carafe is ergonomically-designed with a wide mouth opening for convenient cleaning with a damp towel and spout which prevents spillage and dripped coffee while pouring.
The included LCD screen includes a timer of up to 120 minutes which displays the time that has passed since the coffee was brewed.
The compact size, low pricing, LCD display, auto shut-off and 24-hour programmable auto brew function has made this unit popular with customers who recommend it as the best 12 cup thermal coffee maker in the market. Additionally, this model allows you to pause brewing to pour out coffee and monitor water level with an indicator alert.
The manufacturer recommends switching to a screen basket filter and flushing the heater with vinegar water solution to remove scale buildup from hard water.
Reported customers complaints include the lack of memory recall after power outage which necessitates resetting the time and the non-detachable water tank.
The Capresso 485.05 MT600 Plus mainly features stainless steel construction in most of its components. This material is found in the double-walled thermal carafe to keep the brewed coffee hot for up to 4 hours, in the lining of the heating system to limit decalcification which is accelerated when water comes into contact with aluminum, and in the housing to make a sturdy unit which does not leave fingerprints. We like the replacement of alloy in its predecessor with aluminum and the wider carafe opening in this upgraded version.
This model has a capacity of ten cups of coffee which it brews in less than eight minutes. A 24-hour timer allows you to program brewing to start at your ideal time while the preset settings automatically use optimal temperature when brewing smaller batches of 3 to 5 cups. Once a brewing cycle is completed, the appliance automatically shuts off for safety and energy-saving purposes.
This is the best thermal carafe coffee maker for filtering chlorine and other impurities from water which may affect the flavor of your drink because it comes with a permanent washable and dishwasher safe GoldTone filter and a charcoal water filter. After 60 pots of coffee, a built-in counter triggers a blinking green light to remind you to replace the charcoal filter.
You can pause brewing to serve yourself coffee, monitor the water level with the included indicator and see the settings in use on the LED display.
The only drawback we could find is the non-removable water tank and the filter holder which does not always fit snugly.
What makes it stand out?
Water and filter indicators
Pause and serve capability
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
Filter holder does not fit closely
Things to Consider
In this guide, we look at the benefits of owning a thermal carafe coffee maker, the key features to consider before buying one, and how to maintain your unit to maintain peak performance and enhance longevity.
Advantages of thermal coffee makers
The best automatic drip coffee maker with thermal carafe feature double-walled insulation that keeps your freshly brewed coffee hot for several hours.
Thermal coffee makers preserve the aroma and flavor of coffee by avoiding additional heat which may cause over-extraction and a burnt taste.
They come with programmable settings and preset brewing options which makes the process convenient and offer versatile customizable coffee blends.
Their sturdy stainless-steel construction makes them durable.
Features to consider while choosing a thermal coffee maker
These are the key factors that determine the best drip coffee makers with thermal carafe.
Your coffee consumption will determine the ideal capacity you should consider before buying the best automatic drip coffee maker with thermal carafe. Manufacturers typically indicate the number of cups that their appliances will dispense so you don’t have to make many batches to meet your demand.
Some models also allow you to customize the brew strength and the volume of your drink so you can make fewer cups of the same coffee flavor or another specialty blend without compromising the taste and aroma of the brew. For example, both the Cuisinart DCC-3400 and the BLACK+DECKER Thermal Coffee Maker have a 12-cup capacity but also let you brew 1 to 4 cups. With the Zojirushi EC-YTC100XB Coffee Maker, you can brew 10 cups of hot coffee or up to 5 cups of concentrated iced coffee.
If it’s programmable
Programmable coffee makers allow you to set the unit to automatically operate in your chosen settings. They let you adjust the volume and strength of the brew, set brewing time and schedule the unit with a timer to start brewing at a specified time so you can have your coffee ready when you need it. They may also feature preset settings for different servings and specialty drinks. Majority of the models we have recommended can be customized to your desired settings for more personalized output. They include the Breville BDC450 Precision Brewer Coffee Maker which boasts of six built-in brewing modes of Gold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew, and My Brew for varied blends. It also features three flow rate options and lets you adjust bloom time.
Filters come in permanent or disposable form to eliminate odor, chlorine and other impurities from water to avoid impacting the final brew flavor or causing scale buildup from sediments.
The Capresso MT600 and the Cuisinart DCC-3400 come with a permanent washable dishwasher safe GoldTone filter and a charcoal water filter which should be replaced when the filter indicator light alerts you.
A permanent filter is convenient because you can wash it and reuse it without incurring additional costs on replacement. Confirm the cost and availability of disposable filters for convenient replacement.
This is a safety feature which turns off the unit when the brewing cycle is completed to protect the unit from damage and lower your utility bills.
Before purchasing the best 12 cup coffee maker with thermal carafe, consider its dimensions to ensure you have sufficient space to accommodate it as well as other appliances. Most of the products we have featured in this review can be easily placed on the counter due to their compact size and small footprint. The BUNN Velocity Brew 10-Cup Coffee Brewer is among the most portable coffee brewers with dimensions of 14.2 x 9.2 x 2 inches.
Familiarize yourself with the respective warranties for different models for the best security against any future malfunctioning and for guidance on replacement. Online feedback from buyers and review sites would be a great place to learn more about the best automatic drip coffee maker with thermal carafe in the market.
For how long coffee remains hot: The best coffee makers come with thermal carafes made of double-walled stainless steel for superior insulation and heat retention. They keep the coffee at its brewed temperature without heating it further to preserve its aroma and flavor and avoid over-extraction and a bitter or burnt taste. The duration ranges from one model to another, typically from 2 hours to 12 hours. Most of the featured products will keep your coffee hot for at least four hours.
Brewing options: Multiple settings which can be adjusted to customize the volume, strength and brewing time of your coffee allow you to personalize your drink to your preferences and experiment with several specialty blends. The best illustration of this is the Breville BDC450 which boasts of six built-in brewing modes of Gold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew, and My Brew for varied blends. It also features three flow rate options and lets you adjust bloom time. Other examples include the Cuisinart DCC-3400 and the BLACK+DECKER Thermal Coffee Maker which come with regular and bold, and regular, strong, and bold brew strength options respectively as well as the Zojirushi EC-YTC100XB Coffee Maker which brews 10 cups of hot coffee or up to 5 cups of concentrated iced coffee.
Controls: Beginners who like the simplicity of few settings and baristas who prefer control over convenience in all stages of brewing would be best served by the best coffee maker with grinder and thermal carafe or the BUNN BT Velocity Brew 10-Cup Coffee Brewer which has minimal preset settings. Otherwise, digital displays, intuitive buttons and built-in settings are convenient and time-saving options.
How to maintain your thermal coffee maker
Check the included manual for instructions on how to operate and maintain your specific unit.
Look out for alert indicators for water level, cleaning or replacement and act accordingly.
Use a water filter to remove contaminants and reduce accumulation of sediments in the unit.
Remove and wash the filter basket, permanent filter, decanter and decanter lid in a solution of hot water and mild liquid soap.
Clean the filter basket, permanent and washable filter, carafe and the lid with hot water and soap, or in a dishwasher if it is safe to do so.
Thermal carafes vary in their heat retention capacity, depending on the model and the construction material. For instance, the BUNN BT Velocity Brew 10-Cup Coffee Brewer warms your brewed coffee for 2 hours while the Capresso MT600 keeps fresh coffee hot for 4 hours. While the most common duration is an average of 4 hours, double-walled stainless-steel carafes that are well-insulated can keep coffee hot for 6 to 12 hours.
Reheating coffee with a microwave or keeping it hot with a heating plate results in over-extraction and a drink with bitter taste. This is why you should invest in the best thermal carafe coffee maker which effectively keeps your coffee fresh and hot for hours without using a heating element that would overcook the coffee and compromise its flavor.
Filtered water is essential when making coffee in order to remove odor, chlorine and other contaminants which may affect the final flavor of your coffee and sediments which could cause scale buildup and clog your unit.
The Cuisinart DCC-3400 makes coffee brewing more convenient with features such as high 12-cup capacity, a programmable timer, dual water filters, self-clean and memory recall capabilities, backlit LCD screen, and pause brew and serve function.
Our second pick for the best 12 cup coffee maker with thermal carafe is the SCA-certified Breville BDC450 with versatile brewing settings which include 6 brewing modes, 3 flow rates, Thermocoil Heating System, and adjustable bloom and brew time for varied coffee flavor. We also like the optional adapter for pour over drinks.
The BUNN Velocity Brew 10-Cup Coffee Brewer is for baristas who cherish controlling almost every stage of brewing to produce coffee with a personal unique flavor. The high brewing speed of 10 cups of coffee in 3 minutes, which remains hot for 2 hours without compromising flavor, compensates for the non-programmable settings and provides one of the best thermal carafe coffee makers on the market.