Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Can't decide between Nespresso and Keurig? We compared them for you.
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updated: August 10, 2021
vs
Can't decide between Nespresso and Keurig? We compared them for you.
Coffee Statistics is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Nespresso and Keurig are both coffee machine brand giants that need no introduction. The two coffee titans are popular for their top-quality machines. They both put so much detail into building their machines ensuring you have the best coffee making experience both for commercial purpose and home use.

Although both brands offer fantastic options for brewing lattes, cappuccinos, and all kinds of coffee with the benefits of single-serve coffee pod technology there’s one that outdoes the other in one way or another. So, which of the machines is best for you? You need comprehensive knowledge of each of them to make the tough choice. Read on to discover what you need and can afford.

Brands comparison

Nespresso and Keurig are the biggest names in the coffee world but how to the 2 coffee bigwigs differ?

Keurig

Keurig is popularly known to be a brand that targets the average coffee drinker. This notion is pretty evident in the build of all their models. They are simple and easy to use, yet highly functional.

Keurig is a top contender in the single-serve coffee realm because its products offer superior durability and functional efficiency. They are also reasonably priced.

Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Nespresso

Nespresso was founded by the world-famous coffee brand Nestle. It is a brand more suited for coffee connoisseurs and espresso. With a Nespresso machine you get the fancy cup of coffee with rich, and strong aroma that everyone dreams of.

Nespresso machines don’t come cheap but you can count on them to offer you quality and consistency. Their newer VertuoLine has however become more affordable. Nestle was probably trying to acquire more market share from its pod coffee competitors.

Nespresso and Keurig: comparing popular models

Nespresso and Keurig each have manufactured several single-serve coffee machines with different bells and whistles. We will be comparing some of their most popular models; the Nespresso Citiz vs Keurig K-select and Nespresso Vertuo and Keurig K-Café.

Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi vs. Keurig K-Select Coffee Makers

Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi Keurig K-Select
Coffee preparation Espresso, Long Espresso
Pump pressure 19 bar n/a
Water tank capacity 34 oz. 52 oz.
Used capsule container capacity 10 n/a
Cup sizes 1.35, 5 oz. 6, 8, 10, 12 oz
Memory function yes no
Auto shut-off yes yes
Dimensions 5.1 x 14.6 x 10.9 in 12.5 x 9.2 x 11.6 in
Weight 7.5 lbs. 7.3 lbs.
Warranty 1-year 1-year
Available colors Black, white Black, white, navy, oasis, sandstone, vintage red
VIEW ON AMAZON VIEW ON AMAZON

Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi overview

This is one of Nespresso’s high-quality Swiss made machines highly preferred for rich and authentic shots of espresso. Nespresso employs the Centrifusion technology to force water rapidly through finely ground coffee beans. This machine mimics a professional espresso machine.

With the unique 19-bar extraction system, Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi makes the most delicious coffee worth every penny you spend on the machine. Plus, it comes with the Aerrocino milk frother that steams your milk with a simple press of a button.

The machine also features a thermo block technology and a stainless steel heating element that ensures your coffee brews at the ideal temperature.

Why you should buy the Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi

It brews high-quality authentic espresso

If you dream of having European-style espresso every morning, then this machine should be your prime consideration. It owes its quality and tasty coffee to the Nespresso pods that have 16 different blends with multiple taste profiles and intensities. Your first purchase of the machine comes with 12 capsules. Each capsule contains a curated blend of high-quality coffee from all over the world. Nespresso even provides a wealth of information on the origins of the capsules.

Solid durability

You can count on the Swiss made Nespresso machine to withstand the test of time. It is made to last with thick plastic and a sturdy metallic exterior. They have faith in the build quality of the machine and have backed it with a 2-year warranty.

Sleek design

The Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi comes in a sleek space saving design. It won’t feel like another device cramping up your counter space. Its sleek design will give your coffee station an aesthetic appeal.

Easy to recycle Nespresso pods

Nespresso offers a free coffee pods recycling program. Your purchase comes with a free recycling bag that you can drop at any of their offices.

Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Drawbacks

It is costlier

The machine is more expensive to purchase and operate than the K-select. You would have to buy the coffee capsules which are about 75 to 90 cents each.

Small water reservoir

The water reservoir only holds up to 40 ounces of water. Therefore, you would have to refill it at least every 4 servings.

Keurig K-select overview

This is the ultimate easy-to-use on the go coffee maker. It is incredibly affordable, makes great coffee consistently and has a decent functionality.

Why you should buy the K-Select

Top-notch functionality

The machine comes in different sizes. You can choose the 6, 8, 10, or 12 ounces size. It also features an enormous water reservoir of 52 ounces. You wouldn’t have to refill it every other time after a few coffees.

Another sleek feature of the K-select is its ‘strong-brew’ setting that can give your coffee that extra kick regardless of your cup size. It also features a removable drip tray that allows you fit your travel mug or thermos whenever you are making a quick one on your commute.

Easy to use

As with all Keurig coffee makers, the K-select is remarkably user-friendly. Its operation is pretty straightforward. All you need to do to make yourself a cup of coffee is select a cup size, put in your K-cup then push a button to have your coffee ready in less than 60 seconds.

Quiet

The K-select employs the quiet brew technology that makes it less noisy than many other coffee makers. You won’t have to worry about waking up everyone in the house just because of an early cup of coffee. It is also sustainable and energy efficient because it turns off automatically after 2 hours of inactivity.

Tasty brew

If you like the taste of drip coffee, then you can never go wrong with a Keurig. It uses 15 bars of pressure to provide a consistent and tasty brew.

Design

K-select has a sleek, stylish design that will elevate your kitchen aesthetically. It comes in myriad color options including red, green, navy, matte white and matte black. However, it is not the smallest Keurig owing to its huge water reservoir. You have to create enough space for it on your Kitchen counter.

Easy maintenance

K-select is made with a finger-print resistant material. You wouldn’t have to wipe the machine constantly especially if you get it in matte black. Plus, its drip tray can hold up to 8 ounces of spilled coffee and you can easily clean it in the dishwasher.

Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Drawbacks

Mineral build up

The K-select like other Keurigs gets mineral buildup in the water reservoir making maintenance a bit of a hassle. The mineral builder also makes the machine struggle with the brewing process.

Which one should you buy?

If you want a strong concentrated shot of espresso with rich flavors, then dig deeper into your pockets for the Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi. It comes second to none in terms of brewing flavorful coffee. The K-select uses 15 bars of pressure but will never be able to extract a flavorful concentrated shot of espresso like the Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi

If you are up for a low-budget option and you love the taste of drip coffee then the K-select should be your top consideration. It is also easier to use and more affordable to purchase and operate.

The Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi is also smaller and sleeker than the K-Select because of its relatively smaller water reservoir. You wouldn’t have to create much space on the counter for it but you should be prepared to refill the tank after a few rounds of coffee.

Breville Nespresso Vertuo vs. Keurig K-Cafe 

Breville Nespresso Vertuo Keurig K-Cafe
Coffee preparation  Espresso, Mug Espresso, 2 oz shot Latte & Capp
Pump pressure CENTRIFUSION™
Water tank capacity 40 oz 60 oz.
Used capsule container capacity 13-20 n/a
Cup sizes 8, 1.35 oz. 6, 8, 10, 12 oz.
Memory function no no
Auto shut-off yes yes
Dimensions 8.32 x 11.91 x 11.93 in. 12 x 8.8 x 15 n.
Weight 12.34 lbs. 13.2 lbs.
Warranty 1-year 1-year
Available colors black, titan, chrome, matte black, red charcoal, nickel
VIEW ON AMAZON VIEW ON AMAZON

Keurig K-Cafe overview

Keurig’s most popular model is the K-café. It is famous because of its reasonable price point. It is also super-easy to use and thanks to its K-cup, it produces the most delicious coffee. The k-café is easily portable, and perfect for anyone on the go.

It also comes with a portable frother that you can use to make café quality cappuccinos and lattes on the go. This is in fact its most distinguishing feature as most drip coffee makers don’t include a portable frother.

Moreover, the K-café features a humongous 60-ounce water reservoir. This allows you to brew up to 6 cups of coffee without refilling. If you are using it for a single-serve, you can make several 2-ounce shots of lattes and cappuccinos or a full 12-ounce coffee.

Why you should buy the K-café

Affordable

Like all the other Keurigs, the K-café is incredibly affordable. The K-cups are like 35 to 65 cents and you can buy the reusable ones.

Easy to use

The K-café is remarkably user-friendly. It has cool features like a color touch LCD display temperature control, a water filter and a programmable clock for added convenience. It also has a built-in frother that allows you to make lattes and cappuccinos with a simple press of a button. As if that’s enough, it has a ‘cold’ setting for iced coffee drinks.

Large reservoir

The K-café can hold a whopping 60 ounces of water. You can literally make 6 rounds of coffee before refilling it.

Drawbacks

Short-warranty

The K-café only has a 1-year warranty cover which is a bit short compared to other within its range.

Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Nespresso Vertuo overview

The Nespresso Vertuo is Nespresso’s most famous model. It is a top favorite for many coffee aficionados because it is a full package and it offers an unmatched authentic taste. Using it is a breeze and it comes with coffee pods that will give you consistent crema-packed flavor shots that will definitely leave you sufficiently caffeinated.

Operating the machine is easy-breezy. All you have to do is push a single button to get the water heated then wait for a rich and tantalizing brew trickle into your cup. Having your coffee in less than 15 seconds will have you rethinking the entire process of filling a portafilter on an espresso machine.

You can enhance your coffee brewing experience with the Aeroccino, which is a gadget that heats milk that you can add to your brew to make it special. You can create latte art with it or a coffeehouse design froth.

Why you should buy the Nespresso Vertuo

Easy to use

The machine works with the touch of a single button. It creates its own foam and it produces very little noise and vibration. It also cleans itself with a self-cleaning cycle that uses hot-water. Maintenance is also breeze because its air tight capsule barely leak.

Top quality brew

The Vertuo outdoes itself by making top, rich authentic brews. It owes the high-quality brews to Nespresso’s premium capsules that have a unique flavor that gets released when they are brewed.

The most exciting feature is the blend recognition system that recognizes every capsule inserted in the machine with a barcode. This means that every coffee capsule is brewed uniquely hence the unbeatable brew quality.

Design

The Vertuo has a well-designed, compact and efficient build. It is practically sturdy and you can trust it to last you a good one. Its sleek design will add a touch of class to your coffee station.

Drawbacks

Less control

The Nespresso Vertuo does not give you control over the strength of the brew and the amount of water to use.

Costly

The Nespresso capsules used with the Nespresso Vertuo are not the cheapest out there.

Nespresso vs Keurig: Which Brand to Choose?

Which one should you buy?

Brew quality

Nespresso Vertuo is the winner here. Nothing comes close to the flavorful Nespresso capsules. They deliver rich and authentic brews. They are hermetically sealed and have unique flavors trapped in them that get released when brewed. K-café coffee is good but Nespresso Vertuo coffee is super-great.

Ease of use

Nespresso Vertuo wins again. All you have to do to make yourself a cup is press a single button. Plus, it cleans itself. The K-café has multiple control options that you must wrap your head around if you are new to coffee makers.

Cost

The k-café is the winner here. The K-cups used with coffee pods are much cheaper than the premium Nespresso capsules. Though they produce a weaker coffee taste, they are much cheaper. The purchasing price of the K-Café is also comparably lower than that of Nespresso Vertuo.

Control

If control is what you are looking for. Like if you love to decide how strong your coffee is, then you should go with the K-café. It allows you to dictate the amount of water to use and the strength of the brew. It also has a setting that adds that strong and authentic taste to your coffee if you want.

The Nespresso Vertuo on the other hand, does not offer flexibility on the strength of the brew you want. All you have to do is press a button to get coffee that resembles fine espresso. You don’t get much control over it.

Innovation

Coffee equipment manufacturers are getting more innovative these days. Keurig’s K-cups idea was a hot revolutionary idea as it allowed coffee drinkers to make a single cup of coffee on-the-go. The innovation has grown old by now compared to Nespresso’s genius idea of having coffee capsules with a blend of flavors from all over the world.

As if that’s enough, Nespresso went ahead to create a blend recognition system that allows the coffee machine to brew each capsule to its maximum flavor automatically. This is what sets their brew quality apart. If you add the Aeroccino froth onto the whole package, it becomes hard to beat Nespresso.

What’s more, the Nespresso capsules are recyclable. If you are looking for an eco-friendly option you should consider this. The bottom line is, in terms of innovation, Nespresso is the undisputed winner.

Final thoughts

The Nespresso vs Keurig debate has been going on for ages. Both the giant coffee brands are good at what they do as they produce top-quality machines that are market leaders. The comparison between their most popular models have shown their strengths and weaknesses and for each comparison there is a clear winner. Nespresso is the way to go if you value high-quality brew. Both the Nespresso Citiz Original by De’Longhi and the Nespresso Vertuo are fantastic options if you want coffeehouse quality espresso with rich flavors every morning.

If you are a casual coffee drinker and would love a machine that allows you to have different tastes of coffee then you should definitely go for a Keurig. Both K-select and K-café are perfect options for drip coffee on the go. They are also much cheaper to buy and operate. The capsules of Nespresso are costly but worth every penny when they get to your cup.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *