7 Best Organic Coffee K-Cup Brands – Best Compatibility and Quality!

We came up with the 7 best organic coffee K-Cup brands listed below, both in terms of flavor and value for money.
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: September 02, 2021
Coffee Statistics is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Coffee Statistics is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

People with Keurig-branded brewers are limited to K-Cup use as they’re the only things that will work with their machines. This, however, doesn’t mean they should settle for lower quality coffees.

There are more than enough companies making compatible organic coffee products, and it’s worth exploring which ones are excellent and the ones that are just ‘meh’. Having taste-tested and examined the different qualities of the options available, we came up with a few of the best organic coffee K-Cups in the market listed below. The qualities in question include the type of coffee, origins, roast options, flavors and pack size. These tell the full story of what the buyer should expect especially with regard to the taste.

7 Best Organic Coffee K-Cup Brands Review 2021

1.

Newman's Own Organics Special BlendEditor’s Choice

Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: Central America, Indonesia
  • Roast: medium, dark
  • Taste: Special Blend, Decaf Special Blend, French Roast, Sunrise Blend
  • Pack size: 32-96

More features: Fair Trade certified coffee, USDA organic, Kosher, certified frustration-free packaging

The Newman’s Own Organics Coffee Pods is a blend of Arabica-type coffee sourced from both Indonesia and Central America. It’s available in medium and darker roasts, which means it will likely have a full-bodied flavor. In addition to being certified Organic, it’s approved by a few other organizations and hence is one of the top options available. There is also a variety of taste and flavor options in the purchase.

This pack seems like a lot of value for anyone who wants to switch up tastes and flavors as they go. You can buy decaf this time and the sunrise blend in your next purchase. The pack size can also be large enough for families if necessary.

What makes it stand out?

  • With pack size options that range between 32 and 96, you’re sorted if you’re an individual who takes multiple coffees a day. The same is true if the pack is intended to cater to multiple individuals in the household. We also liked that there are four variable flavor options meaning you can switch up the flavors on consecutive orders if you want to. Lastly, it doesn’t just cater to organic coffee drinkers. It caters to Jews and is Fair Trade Certified.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • The consistency may be an issue. We noticed that you could love the flavor in one pod and then be utterly disappointed by the next. This is especially true for the decaf, which in our opinion, tastes a little watered down. Nevertheless, the flavor was spot on more than 90% of the time for the other batches. Another con is how there are no light roast options. Consequently, if you prefer non-traditional coffee flavors, the Newman's Own Organics Coffee Pods might not work for you.
Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: not specified
  • Roast: medium
  • Taste: toasty and bold, nutty notes
  • Pack size: 100

More features:  Fair Trade-certified, USDA-certified, Kosher Certified, compatible with all 1.0 & 2.0 brewers

Next is the Caza Trail Organic Extra Bold Coffee Pods, which again uses Arabica coffee, although the origins of the beans are unclear. It is medium-roasted before being packed in K-Cups and shipped to you. The box also ships with 100 K-Cups included.

Those who can’t seem to choose between the floral notes of light-roasted coffee and the body of darker roasts have a viable option in the medium-roasted Caza Trail Organic Extra Bold Coffee Pods. Furthermore, its compatibility with both 1.0 & 2.0 brewers means whatever machine you own will work just fine.

What makes it stand out?

  • There are 100 K-Cups in each box, and consequently, you can max out on your coffee quota every day without worrying about running out. Also, just like the Newman's Own Organics Coffee Pods, Jews can take the coffee without going against their religious beliefs. In our opinion, the medium-roast of this coffee also works if you like both bold coffees that are characteristic of dark roasts and floral, fruity tones that are more common in light roasts.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • While it does strike a good middle ground between tastes, some drinkers would rather have either bold or floral tones, and this K-Cup coffee option doesn’t offer that. Like its predecessor, the Newman's Own Organics Coffee Pods, we noticed some inconsistencies in flavor. One batch might be bold as described, while another may have a few hints of bitterness here and there. For buyers who want the same coffee taste every time they get a delivery, it may be a tall order with this option.
Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: Indonesia
  • Roast: dark
  • Taste: sweet palate of brown sugar and spice notes
  • Pack size: 24

More features:  Fair Trade Certified and USDA Organic, Orthodox Union Kosher

With the Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups option, buyers get a 24-pack set with each purchase. Despite being from Indonesia, it is unlike most other Indonesian Robusta coffees that are earthy and feature a lasting aftertaste. What you do get are brown sugar and spice notes.

Since there are only 24 K-Cups in each pack, it’s safe to say that this works better for single-person households. It could also work if there are no avid coffee drinkers in the home.

What makes it special?

  • We liked the taste notes of the coffee, which certainly aren’t the norm with coffees from Indonesia. Nevertheless, it’s a welcome surprise that might be as a result of the roast. Furthermore, with a Fair Trade certification, this coffee is sustainably sourced in terms of both the environment and the workers who ensure you get the coffee while at home. The Orthodox Union Kosher certification is a bonus and makes the coffee accessible to more people, especially Jews.

What cons did we find?

  • Once we did the math, we noticed that the Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups are some of the most expensive K-Cup options in the market. However, given the taste and consistency, it is still good value for money. Also, only offering dark roasts is bound to leave some potential customers disgruntled, especially those who prefer light roasts since the flavors are far apart. Lastly, the pack size might not work for those who drink multiple coffees a day.
4.

AmazonFresh 80 Ct. Organic Fair Trade K-CupsBest USA-Processed K-Cups

Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: Peru, Sumatra
  • Roast: medium, dark
  • Taste: fragrant with a smooth finish; deep, intense flavor
  • Pack size: 80

More features: Fair Trade certified, USDA Organic, roasted and packed in the USA

Like the Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups, some of the AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups use beans sourced from Sumatra. These are dark roasted which gives them a deep, intense, full-bodied flavor. There’s also another variation of these K-Cups that uses Peruvian beans, only this time they’re medium roasted.

With the medium and dark roasts both available, these pods are great for various coffee lovers. Those who prefer the quality of US-made products also can’t go wrong with these K-Cups.

What stands out?

  • The choice between Peruvian and Sumatran sourced coffee is something we liked. In case you’re unsure or still new to coffees and their different flavors and aromas, you can try both before picking one that you’ll stick with. Of course, these two offer you dual flavor profiles as well, with one reason for this being the different roast types. The Peruvian is smoother, while the Sumatran is deeper and more intense.

What cons did we manage to find?

  • Having considered the needs of coffee drinkers who prefer dark and medium roasts, you have to feel for light-roast coffee drinkers since they’re left out yet again. Also, unlike all other K-Cup offerings listed before, the AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups pack isn’t Kosher certified. Consequently, Jews cannot use these pods. Next, since all the 80 K-Cups are packed loosely in the shipping box, we noticed that getting at least one spill is a fairly common occurrence. Finally, there are no smaller pack sizes available.
5.

SF Bay Coffee OneCUP Organic Rainforest BlendBest Pack Size Options

Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: Central America
  • Roast: medium-dark
  • Taste: full-bodied, with notes of sweet berry and dark chocolate
  • Pack size: 12, 36, 80

More features: USDA certified, CCOF certified

The Organic Rainforest Blend is one of five K-Cup varieties offered by the SF Bay Coffee OneCUP store. Sourced from Central America, the beans are medium-dark roasted before they’re ground and packed into the K-Cups. The Central American roots are somewhat responsible for the dark chocolaty flavor infused with sweet berries.

This K-Cup offering works for households of different sizes due to the 12, 36, and 80-Cup pack sizes. Also, given its medium-dark roast, it’s better for coffee drinkers who prefer full-bodied beverages.

Why are we impressed?

  • In our opinion, having 12, 36, and 80-cup pack sizes makes it easier to sell to a broader market. One reason is that it caters to more budgetary options. Next, whether you live alone or your household has multiple people, there’s a pack for everyone. Also, the K-Cups are California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF) certified, which is an organization that holds as much water as the USDA in terms of organic certifications.

What negatives must you be aware of?

  • A theme that’s come up multiple times on this list is that light-roast drinkers are underrepresented with regards to K-Cup options, and it’s no different with the SF Bay Coffee OneCUP Organic Rainforest Blend. Additionally, some of the K-Cups tend to burst while brewing. This can interrupt the brewing process or introduce some of the grinds into the coffee. Having to clean up the aftermath after such an event can also be annoying.
6.

Cameron's Coffee Organic Breakfast BlendBest Light Roast Organic K-Cups

Features
  • Type: Arabica
  • Origin: Central and South America
  • Roast: light, dark
  • Taste: Organic Breakfast Blend, Organic French Roast
  • Pack size: 12

More features: allergen-free, gluten-free, 100% compostable pods

Next is the Cameron’s Coffee Organic Breakfast Blend, which is the only light-roast option listed. It’s also available as a dark roast, although medium roasts have been left out of the mix. It comes in a 12 pack box, with each K-Cup costing about $0.50. Worth mentioning is that the K-Cups included are compostable in addition to being both allergen and gluten-free.

These coffees work best if you’re prone to allergic reactions or you can’t take gluten. Furthermore, given the compostable nature of the K-Cups, it becomes infinitely easier to dispose of them without damage to the environment.

Why are we impressed?

  • It’s not often that you find allergen and gluten-free coffee, something we were pleasantly impressed by. Furthermore, people who prefer light roasts finally have a top tier option that was worth the inclusion on the list. However, the light roast is only for the Organic Breakfast Blend. The Organic French Roast, on the other hand, is dark roasted. Lastly, since the K-Cups are compostable, they leave a smaller carbon footprint than most other alternatives listed.

What negatives must you be aware of?

  • You do pay for the extra convenience of the compostable pods in addition to the elimination of allergens. As such, we noticed the average cost of each K-Cup is about $0.50, which is relatively pricy. Most other organic coffees average about $0.30, and so anyone looking to save might end up picking something else. The lack of a kosher certification also means it might be inaccessible to Jews as they honor their religion.
7.

DEATH WISH Death Cups and VALHALLA JAVA Odinforce BlendBest Themed Organic Coffee K-Cups

Features
  • Type: Arabica and Robusta
  • Origin: Indonesia and Central and South America,
  • Roast: dark
  • Flavor: artisan flavor, robust aroma; subtle, never bitter cherry and chocolate flavor profile
  • Pack size: 20

More features: USDA Certified Organic, Fair Trade, 100% recyclable

The DEATH WISH Death Cups and VALHALLA JAVA Odinforce Blend features dark-roast coffee, which matches the color theme of the K-Cups. Additionally, it’s the only blend listed which incorporates two types of coffees. The resulting coffee is quite a mix of flavors and aromas.

For fans of Norse Mythology, the DEATH WISH Death Cups and VALHALLA JAVA Odinforce Blend seem like an appropriate purchase. However, that only applies if you also like dark roast coffee.

Why are we impressed?

  • In our opinion, themed K-Cup seals add extra fun to the purchase, brewing process, and overall experience of the coffee. The dark exterior of the K-Cups and the top seal also seem to fit the theme quite well. Another thing we liked that you might as well is the mix of Robusta and Arabica beans that gives the coffee some exciting flavors and aromas. Lastly, the K-Cup containers may not be compostable, but they are recyclable.

What negatives must you be aware of?

  • Although many people are, not everyone is a fan of Norse mythology, and as such, the theme and branding may put some people off. Furthermore, the dark roast is appropriate for the dark colors of the containers, but there’s no denying that medium-roast and light-roast lovers have not been catered to. Even Jews may have to avoid this coffee due to a lack of Kosher certifications. Lastly, we noticed each K-Cup could cost $1.44, making this organic coffee option the most expensive on the list and one of the most pricey in the market.

Things to Consider

Picking the best organic coffee K-Cups is more of a science than an art. There are specific markers and attributes you look at that indicate quality. That said, you might miss them if you don’t know what they are. Here’s a buying guide on organic K-Cup coffees to help you figure it out.

Benefits of Organic Coffee

The biggest benefit of any organic farm product is the lack of chemicals like pesticides and artificial fertilizers that are generally considered unhealthy for consumption. The high antioxidant, mineral, and vitamin content are also some extra upsides.

How to Pick the Best Organic Coffee K-Cups

Here’s precisely how to pick the best organic coffee K-Cups after looking through your options. Notably, even when using the same process, most people will come up with different results as the best organic coffee K-Cups for each individual will depend on their tastes.

Type of Beans

7 Best Organic Coffee K-Cup Brands - Best Compatibility and Quality!

Arabica beans, with their fruity notes and an acidic profile, are twice as popular as robusta

Arabica, Robusta, are the two main types of coffee beans in production today, although there are other unique ones as well. Statistics by the International Coffee Organization Trusted Source International Coffee Organization - What's New
Trade Statistics – July 2021
• World coffee exports amounted to 10.61 million bags in July 2021, compared with 10.47 million in July 2020.
• Exports in the first 9 months of coffee year 2020/21 (Oct/20 to July/21) have increased by 2.1% to 108.92 million bags compared to 106.63 million bags in the same period in 2019/20.
ico.org
assert that Arabica exports in the world for the financial year ending June 2021 are almost twice as much as Robusta exports.

This might explain why you’re more likely to find Arabica Organic Coffee K-Cups than you are to find Robusta. Arabica beans tend to be more aromatic with fruity, floral notes and an acidic profile. Conversely, Robusta coffees feature earthy tones, a peanut-like aftertaste, and less acidity.

Most people prefer Arabica coffees like the AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups, which explains the market statistics. However, some would rather have Robusta coffee any day of the week. As such, you can pick one type of coffee or the other depending on the flavor profile you prefer.

Origin

According to information provided by the World Population Review Trusted Source Coffee Producing Countries 2021 Did you know that coffee starts as fruit from cherry trees? That’s right! Coffee beans are made from cherries. And like every product that starts as a seed and becomes a plant before the finished product surfaces, coffee does not grow well or sustainably in all parts of the world. What you will find when looking at coffee producing countries is that most of the countries that produce coffee share similar characteristics in terms of the geographic area. worldpopulationreview.com , coffee is grown and exported by about 50 countries globally. Notably, these coffee origins also tend to have quite an impact on flavor.

For instance, Ethiopian coffee is delicate with blueberry, bergamot and jasmine aftertastes. Conversely, Brazilian coffee has nutty flavors and a fairly chocolaty taste.

This theme is repeated with almost every coffee-growing country where the resulting coffee has a different flavor profile.

As such, you should always check the coffee origins before buying K-Cups. Notably, some of the source countries for the coffees in our list include Peru, Indonesia, and some Central American countries like Honduras.

The beans for the Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups, for instance, are sourced from Indonesia.

Roast and Taste

7 Best Organic Coffee K-Cup Brands - Best Compatibility and Quality!

You can find K-cup coffee of all kinds of roast: from light to dark

Although coffee beans come infused with flavor from their source countries, the roast type may also affect the taste. Light roasts like the Cameron’s Coffee Organic Breakfast Blend are acidic and more likely to exhibit the flavors from their origins.

Conversely, you can expect more body in a dark roast and less acidity. However, the flavors from the coffee’s origins will be understated. Medium-roasts are the middle child between these two opposites. Of course, there are medium-dark and medium-light roasts that are nearer to the extremes as well.

Certifications

First, check whether it’s certified organic. After that, you can look for other certifications that are in line with your beliefs. Some examples include Fair Trade and Direct Trade certifications. For Jews, also check if the Coffee is Kosher certified.

Caffeinated vs Decaf

While caffeine is generally safe, some side effects of drinking it include trouble sleeping, tremors, restlessness, and more. As such, some people prefer to avoid it altogether. If you don’t want to take in caffeine but still like a cup of coffee in the morning, you can opt for decaf. It’s the same taste and flavors, only that there will be minimal to no caffeine.

On the list above, only the Newman’s Own Organics Coffee Pods has a decaf option.

Compatibility

7 Best Organic Coffee K-Cup Brands - Best Compatibility and Quality!

All K-Cups listed in this guide are compatible with Keurig 2.0

Also, check the compatibility with your Keurig-branded brewer. If the K-Cup doesn’t work with your machine, then brewing will be difficult. Fortunately, the options mentioned above are compatible with 1.0 and 2.0 brewers. However, when it comes to Keurig Vue machines, that might be a different matter.

Pack Size

For home use, the pack size might also come into play. For instance, single-person households require smaller packs to fit their needs compared to multi-person families and households. As such, have that in mind when you click the purchase button.

FAQ

K-Cups are made of various materials, e.g. plastic, aluminum, plant-based compostable materials and more. As such, some are more eco-friendly than others. Nevertheless, even the ones that aren’t compostable are recyclable, and you can make it work without too much damage to the environment.

Once you’ve bought a K-Cup pack, you have more than a year to consume it. However, just like other coffees, the quality, taste, and aromas will be affected negatively the longer you wait.

Our Verdict

In our opinion, the Newman’s Own Organics Special Blend is a clear favorite. It’s available in different pack-size options and is Kosher Certified. Furthermore, it offers a decaf option which isn’t available in most of the competition. The Caza Trail Organic Extra Bold Coffee Pods option isn’t far behind. With 100 Kosher Certified bold tasting coffees packed in pods, you’ll have more than enough to last you until your next shipment.

Even the Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups is worth an extra mention. The sweet and spicy flavor notes are the icing on the cake. Nevertheless, these are just but a fraction of the best organic coffee K-Cups available. The list gives four other options that could provide you with the right kickstart to your morning. As such, if they match your needs on paper, why not give them a try.

References

1.
International Coffee Organization - What's New

Trade Statistics – July 2021
• World coffee exports amounted to 10.61 million bags in July 2021, compared with 10.47 million in July 2020.
• Exports in the first 9 months of coffee year 2020/21 (Oct/20 to July/21) have increased by 2.1% to 108.92 million bags compared to 106.63 million bags in the same period in 2019/20.
2.
Coffee Producing Countries 2021
Did you know that coffee starts as fruit from cherry trees? That’s right! Coffee beans are made from cherries. And like every product that starts as a seed and becomes a plant before the finished product surfaces, coffee does not grow well or sustainably in all parts of the world. What you will find when looking at coffee producing countries is that most of the countries that produce coffee share similar characteristics in terms of the geographic area.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *